New Car Time

The original plan: When the house was done, I'd planned to trade in my 2015 Subaru Forester XT (above) for an EV—probably a Chevy Bolt or Hyundai Kona, mostly because of their range. But the commercial property debacle ended that plan, and I was forced to downgrade to a fourteen-year-old rust bucket instead (a 2002 Honda CRV, below) to help ease the worst of the financial crunch.

I'd have stuck with that rust bucket to the bitter end—indeed, I'd already invested a few thousand on repairs—but when I discovered that its rear suspension was at risk of catastrophic failure, I needed another car right away. And I refused to get another used car loaded with potential problems. Thus I settled on a 2019 Subaru Crosstrek (below). What drove this decision?

Although I've wanted to go "greener" for a long time, EVs simply aren't ready for the masses yet—even the "affordable" Bolt or Kona. It's tough to beat the base price of $23K for the Crosstrek—probably the most affordable SUV—when an EV would have started at $37K or so (and you couldn't give me a Tesla); besides, even the impressive range of 200+ miles for the Bolt and Kona is no match for a modern internal combustion vehicle, and the Crosstrek delivers pretty impressive mileage. I might have gone with another Forester, but as is so often the case with established car models, the Forester was getting larger every year; it had grown to nearly the size of its bigger brother, the Outback, which was too big for my tastes, not to mention too expensive.

Now, to be fair, I'd also seriously considered a Chevy Spark (above), solely because one can be had for less than $15K. But in the end I simply couldn't stoop that low, because the Crosstrek brought so much to the party for only $8K more: all-wheel drive, impressive ground clearance, an outstanding track record, and a raft of other perks, not to mention styling that's not an embarrassment. And given that I live at the end of a half-mile driveway, only some of which occasionally gets plowed, I've come to appreciate the advantages—and, in particular, the safety—of a car like the Crosstrek.

So, while I regret not being able to jump on the EV bandwagon, I'm actually more comfortable with the choice I've been "forced" to make, in spite of the fact that it's made finishing my home a bit more difficult. Anyway, I won't be around on Planet Earth much longer, so my Crosstrek—my 12th and, in all likelihood, last car I'll own—won't send us over the tipping point.

Full Car History

For no particular reason other than kicks, here's every car I've owned. (Except for the last one, the photos are not mine, but they're accurate, including the colors.)

1972 Opel Kadette Wagon. I bought my first car from my mother. It put up with a lot of abuse from me, but I also kept it running exceptionally well. But a relatively minor accident spelled doom because a rusted battery clamp broke; the battery crushed the carburetor and caused other significant damage. (Insert sad smiley here.)

1972 Ford Pinto. When the Opel died, I borrowed this wreck from my hobby shop boss. It was in horrible shape and ran like crap, but it lasted long enough for me to save my pennies for something (marginally) better.

1980 Chevy Chevette Scooter. Although my first new car may have been something of an embarrassment, it got me from point A to B reliably enough... until some guy fell asleep at the wheel, blew through a stop sign, and ran me off the road right into a construction site. The impact nearly folded the car in two—vertically. I took the other driver to court and won. Which enabled a significant upgrade...

1981˝ Dodge Charger 2.2. My girlfriend at the time talked me into this beastie, which I bought off the showroom floor. It was actually just a Dodge Omni 024 with a fancy paint scheme and a tuned exhaust that gave the four-banger an impressive throaty growl. But the engine seals began leaking badly after only 50,000 miles—a known issue with this model.

1983 Nissan Sentra Hatchback. My first "adult" car was about as plain vanilla as they come. It was also my first automatic. Although it ran well enough, unfortunately Nissan used crappy steel, and the rear strut mounts rusted through after 3-4 years. I also made the mistake of leasing it, and learned the hard way what happens when your leased car is towed in New York City. Hint: it's a nightmare getting it back. Last time I ever leased.

1983 Honda Civic CRX. I'd had my eye on the CRX for some time, and I finally found a used one for a song. Later, when I looked under the carpet, I found out why it was so cheap: it was very close to becoming a "Flintstone" car, so I didn't keep it long. But it was one of the most fun cars to drive—I still miss this one. (Insert wistful smiley here.)

1986 Honda Civic CRX. Still craving the fun of the nimble CRX, I got another old bucket of rust and tried my best to patch it up. Sadly, I was rear-ended by a distracted driver—right after I'd lost my job, no less. And because it was so old, I got next to nothing for it from insurance.

1999 Suzuki Swift 3-Door. Having to buy a car while I was unemployed forced me to get the absolute cheapest one on the market. But as it happened, this $8K "turdlet" (as I called it) was a remarkably good little car, with unbeatable gas mileage: 50+ MPG! If it only had rack and pinion steering, it would have been nearly as nimble as a CRX. Plus, it had serious driver space—with the seat all the way back, I couldn't reach the pedals (I'm six feet!), and there was at least a half foot of headroom. I even drove around with three adult passengers, and there were no complaints at all. Amazing.

2005 Subaru Forester XT. An excellent new job allowed me to finally ditch the turdlet and get a "real" car, and this Forester delivered quality and performance in spades. It was also the fastest car I'd ever owned—way faster than the Charger. When I retired, I had enough capital to trade up to the 2015 model, which brings us 'round to the beginning of the story.


Copyright © 2017-2019 by David K. Smith. All Rights Reserved.
Home | Top of Page | Site Map